I brought back a half dozen miniatures from my Scottish trip.
4 were purchased in the Wee Couper Of Fife shop in Anstruther – I always call in when passing – 1 was gifted & the last 1 bought at The Kelpies visitor’s centre.
Rather than doing them individually – I thought a blind tasting was in order. Strips out any undue bias towards the selection.
The Tasting
The bottles & identical glasses were numbered & poured with the allocated whisky.
Herself shuffled them around – then I re-entered the room & labelled them A to F.
A quick fire tasting & scoring session ensued.
The result was a clear winner. A bottom scorer & 2 pairs with similar marks.
I wasn’t happy with the shared marks – so went back to separate them.
I must admit the differences were rather subtle with D & F. I gave extra for D’s nose & palate, while F’s finish was better. D eventually got the extra point.
With C & E it was even more close. In all honesty I could have been served these in a bar & not even noticed the difference! As it was – concentrating on them – C marginally came out ever-so-slightly-better.
So now I had a clear gradation from top to bottom – what were they?
I was going to guess – but not having encountered most of these whisky before it would purely be down to inbuilt bias & pure conjecture.
So I didn’t bother.
The Results
My winner was A – No 4 – Seagram’s VO
I’d have expected Glenandrew but no – Seagram’s from Canada was the clear winner! Perhaps the 86.8 proof – 43.4% ABV- should have been a signal. All the others were 40%. This whisky had character!
D was next – No 3 – Glenandrew
A Highland Malt. Only confirms my preference for this region.
F closely followed – No 6 –The Kelpies Blend
Bit of a surprise this one being a bit of a novelty product – yet it’s clearly a decent dram.
Onto C – No 5 – Chivas Regal 12
Now on my bias I’d have given this one last place. Just shows you the surprises blind tasting can reveal!
E came slightly behind – No 2 – Lower East Side
Would have expected a better showing from this new & upcoming Borders Distillery. Yet sharing almost equal footing with an international best seller is not to be dismissed.
B brought up the rear – No 1 – Mackinlay
An old world blended Scotch. Nothing wrong with it. Just didn’t shine in the above company.
Thoughts
So there you go.
A Canadian Whisky wins out over 5 Scotch!
I’d have never guessed that.
The honesty of blind tasting even surprised me here.
The Seagram’s VO was a clear winner which got me wondering why?
Seagram’s VO is now owned by Sazerac & the current bottles appear to be offered at 40%. My one is labelled 86.8 proof & Imported From Canada. I can only assume this is an older offering. I’m also taking it rye is involved. Further reinforcing my appreciation of this flavourful grain.
Conclusion
Explore more Canadian Whisky!
Sláinte